which one will get the boot?

    I've never really thought about wearing boots, but I saw so many bloggers wearing them with ...  well, everything. Girly dresses,  skinnies, bootcut pants, skirts, shorts ...
    I finally succumbed and decided to pick up a pair for my birthday.
    Not long after adored austin posted about Dr. Scholls, Hautelook featured the brand. I couldn't decide between the Allycats bootie and the Addler shootie, so I ordered both, with plans to return one.
    I snagged a little time today to shoot some photos to decide which one suits my (still developing) style best.

Addler shooties

Allycats booties

 FIT: I ordered a 7 for both of these, and found them surprisingly small. I do have to mention that my left foot measures in at about 7, while my right is about 6.5.  Neither shoe is too small, but I would definitely consider trying on a 7.5 if I buy from this brand again. I would have to wear very thin socks with both pairs.

     The round toes on both shoes may not be the most sophisticated, but my toes are smiling. :) My feet are a bit wide, so I'm always looking for shoes with some room in the front. I also like the rather low, chunky heel.

Allycats with bootcut jeans

Addler shooties with bootcut jeans

Allycats with tucked-in skinnies

Allycats with wool schoolgirl skirt

Allycats bootie

PROS: plain leather = good for rainy days; can be worn under bootcuts or over skinnies or leggings.
POSSIBLE CONS: Do they hit me on the wrong spot on my leg and make me look stumpy??

Addler shooties with wool schoolgirl skirt

Addler shooties with CK pencil skirt

Addler shootie

PROS: suede!= <3; ankle bootie, which is recommended for petites.
CONS: suede = not suitable for rainy days; and I'm not sure how to style them. Is it just me, or do they look like elf shoes? I also feel that they look slightly frumpy/old-ladyish in these photos, but maybe it's that I've paired them with the wrong things.

     I'm leaning towards keeping the Allycats, just because I feel more comfortable styling them.
 Which pair do you think I should pick? And how would you style them?